"Why do you dress like that?" Most women who dress modestly have heard some version of the question, from a coworker, a friend, a relative, or sometimes from themselves on a hot afternoon. The honest answer is rarely one sentence. Women choose more coverage for their faith, for family and culture, for comfort, for privacy, or because they like how it looks. Many have more than one reason, and the mix can shift over the years.
This article looks at those reasons and at how they can change, from the teen years through marriage, work, moves and the ordinary changes of adult life. It doesn't set a standard or tell you what to wear. Your standard is yours.
Why do women choose to dress modestly?
There isn't one reason, and women often hold several at once. When psychologist Viren Swami studied hijab wearers in Britain, he told NPR that their reasons "can't be boiled down to one or two things." (NPR) Here are some of the reasons women describe.
Faith. For many women, dress is part of religious practice. In Judaism, tzniut (often pronounced tznius) covers both dress and conduct. A verse often connected with it, Psalm 45:14 in Hebrew Bibles (45:13 in most Christian Bibles), is traditionally rendered "the entire glory of a king's daughter is inward" and read as saying that a woman's dignity lies within. (Sefaria) Many Christian women point to 1 Timothy 2:9, which speaks about modest dress and restraint in adornment. Many Muslim women connect their dress, including the hijab, to their faith. Within each tradition, communities and families set the details differently, so two women of the same faith may not share the same standard.
Family and culture. Some women dress the way the women in their family and community always have, and it feels like home. For others, it keeps a cultural identity visible wherever they live.
Comfort and ease. Some women simply prefer longer skirts, higher necklines and sleeves, and like not having to adjust a neckline or tug at a hem all day.
Privacy. Some women describe modest dress as a way to decide what others see. A writer for Hey Alma who began covering her hair after her wedding wrote that it let her control who perceived her, and how.
Less focus on appearance. Some women say covering takes pressure off. One British study of 587 Muslim women found that those who wore the hijab tended to report more positive body image and less absorption of media beauty ideals than those who didn't; the differences were small, and the study shows an association, not a cause. (Swami et al., 2014; NPR) It looked only at the hijab in Britain, so it says nothing direct about other kinds of modest dress.
Style. Some women just like the look of a long skirt or a high neckline.
Do you have to be religious to dress modestly?
No. Some women dress modestly for reasons that have nothing to do with religion, or only partly to do with it. Writer Lauren Shields spent nine months dressing in a style loosely based on Jewish, Muslim and Christian practice, then stopped covering her hair. Afterward, she said, she chose clothes by asking what she'd be comfortable in for the day ahead. (RNZ)
Who is modesty for: God, yourself, or other people?
That depends on the woman. Some dress modestly for God, some for themselves, some for their family or community, and many for a mix. What we can say plainly is what it isn't for. What a woman wears doesn't make her responsible for anyone else's thoughts or actions, and it doesn't protect her from harm. Respect is something everyone owes everyone, and it's worth teaching boys as deliberately as girls.
Some women find their own answer changes. Bethany Beal, writing for Revive Our Hearts, described losing motivation when she realized she'd been dressing modestly mainly for the young men around her, who didn't seem to appreciate the effort. She kept dressing modestly, but now names her faith as her main reason.
Is it her choice, or someone else's?
Sometimes it's a choice, sometimes an expectation, and often a bit of both. The same skirt can feel freeing when you've chosen it and confining when someone else insists. A piece in Blavity makes the point that covering up out of shame or fear is different from covering up out of personal conviction. We look at choice, control and why some modest clothing feels restrictive in Modesty Is Not What You Think.
When do girls usually start dressing modestly?
It depends on the family and the tradition, and there's no single age. For many girls, modest dress starts as a family custom, a school uniform or a community norm, long before it's a personal decision. Religious traditions have their own teachings on when and how girls begin; in Islam, for example, wearing the hijab is commonly linked to puberty, and some Muslim women choose not to wear it, observing modesty in other ways. (ABC News) If you follow a tradition, your rabbi, teacher or community is the right place to ask what applies to your family. For parents looking for practical ways to talk about it, see How to Teach Girls to Dress Modestly.
What happens when a teenager starts questioning it?
Questioning is part of growing up for many girls, and it doesn't always end where parents or teens expect. Etti Krinsky, who grew up in an observant Chabad family, wrote for Chabad.org about a rebellious phase in high school, when she set modest clothing aside and wore outfits that showed her knees and elbows. Years later, as a young woman working at a day camp, she was asked by a 10-year-old on a 90-degree day: "Why are you wearing winter clothes?"
Krinsky doesn't present herself as having arrived. She writes that she still struggles, follows the guidelines out of respect for her faith and family even on days she isn't feeling it, and hopes her clothes will one day feel like an expression of what's in her heart.
For parents, a teen's questions are worth hearing out rather than treating as rejection. Real choices within your family's standard (color, fit, the pieces she likes wearing) can make the standard feel more like hers. And for the 90-degree days, we have practical ideas in How to Stay Cool and Covered.
Why do some women start dressing modestly as adults?
Some women didn't grow up with modest dress, or let it go for a while, and come to it later: after leaving their parents' home, after becoming more observant or converting, after marriage, or after tiring of keeping up with beauty routines. The Hey Alma writer began covering her hair soon after her wedding. Lauren Shields started her experiment out of frustration with how much effort she felt she had to put into her appearance just to leave the house.
The first few weeks can feel self-conscious. You might feel overdressed on a coffee run in a long skirt, or wonder what people think about your clothes. People do notice how others dress, and sometimes they form opinions. That doesn't mean you need to apologize for dressing according to your standards. Some women start small, with a longer skirt or a layer under a favorite top, and add pieces as they find what works.
Can your reasons for dressing modestly change?
Yes, and for some women they change more than once. Sharon Silver, writing in Tablet, grew up Orthodox and dressed modestly without thinking about it. As a single woman in her late twenties and early thirties, working alongside colleagues who dressed differently, she resented looking different but felt guilty when she cut corners. After she married and had children, modest dress felt settled again, partly because she felt she was representing her husband and children as well as herself.
Community can shift things too. One contributor to a 2011 reader series on tzniut wrote that standards in one Orthodox neighborhood weren't the same as in another, and that she adjusted her dress after moving and after marrying.
Other changes are practical. A new job may come with its own dress norms. Pregnancy, postpartum, weight changes and age can all change what fits and what coverage feels right. Often the answer isn't a new standard or a whole new wardrobe, but different pieces: a longer layer under tops that now sit shorter, a skirt with more stretch, sleeves that suit a warmer climate.
None of this makes an earlier standard wrong. A standard can be steady without being frozen. If it's feeling hard right now, see How to Keep Dressing Modestly When It Feels Hard.
How do you answer "Why do you dress like that?"
Briefly, if you like. A short answer is enough.
- "It's what I'm comfortable in."
- "It's part of my faith."
- "I like how it looks."
The question can come from more than one direction: from people who assume modest dress means insecurity, and sometimes from people in your own community who think you aren't covered enough. Curious questions aren't attacks, and you can answer the ones you want to. Your choice isn't a judgment of other women, and theirs isn't a judgment of yours. If you're worried about how friends will react, we talk about that in Will I Lose Friends Over Dressing Modestly?
What makes modest dressing easier day to day?
Clothes you don't have to think about. Whatever your reasons, the daily frustrations are usually practical: a neckline that gapes when you lean forward, a skirt that rides up when you sit, a top that's almost right if it covered a little more. A higher-neck layering piece under tops you already own, or a skirt length you've checked sitting down, solves more than a closet overhaul. The American Psychological Association's advice for girls makes a similar point in general terms: clothes that need "lots of checking and adjusting" might distract you from school work, friends and other activities, so choose clothes that make you feel comfortable. (APA)
At Kosher Casual, we think of it as Coverage, Comfort and Confidence: the coverage you want, clothes you can live in, and no second-guessing. For more lessons from everyday experience, read 6 Things I Wish I Knew Before Dressing Modestly.
Your reasons, your standard
Modesty can look different for every woman, and different for the same woman at 15, 30 and 60. It may have started as a family rule, a decision you made last month, or something in between. Whatever your reasons, understanding what modest dress means to you can help you navigate the changes life brings.
Have your reasons changed since you started? We'd like to hear how.
Leave a comment