This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $150.00 USD away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

The Sizing Minefield

Woman in a purple three-quarter-sleeve top and a heather grey mid-calf pencil skirt

To choose the right size for a modest, comfortable fit, use the size you usually wear as a starting point, then check it against the item's own measurements and fit notes before you order. Measure yourself and a piece you already love, compare those numbers with the size chart for the exact item you're buying, and read the description to see whether it's designed to fit close or relaxed. Fit notes differ from item to item, so one garment's advice doesn't carry over to another.

Why the Same Size Fits So Differently

If you've ever owned skirts in three different sizes that all fit, it isn't you. There's no enforced universal sizing standard. Each manufacturer cuts for the customer it has in mind: a brand for teens and tweens tends to cut narrower and shorter, and one for grown women more generously.

Fabric changes things too. Knits stretch, so a knit garment can look small and still fit. Woven fabrics don't give, so they're cut with more room.

Size charts aren't all built the same way, either. A body chart tells you the body measurements each size is meant to fit. A garment chart gives the measurements of the clothing itself, which can be larger than your body to allow for movement, or smaller in a stretch fabric meant to fit close. Always check which kind you're reading.

Wanting less fitted clothing for modesty adds one more layer of guesswork. That's why it pays to measure.

Step 1: Measure Yourself

Use a soft tape measure, not a metal one. Stand straight, wear fitted clothing or just underwear, and keep the tape level and snug but not tight. Write each number down.

  • Bust: around the fullest part of your chest, with the tape across your shoulder blades.
  • Waist: at your natural waist, the narrowest part, where your body creases when you bend to the side. Don't hold your breath. Your waist is usually a little larger later in the day.
  • Hips: around the fullest part of your hips. Where that is varies from woman to woman, so measure down from your waist to find it.

A mirror, or a friend, helps you keep the tape level all the way around.

Step 2: Measure Something That Already Fits

This is the most reliable trick, and it's what we recommend to our own customers. Take a skirt or top you love the fit of, lay it flat and measure it the same way garment charts do:

  • Chest: straight across from armpit to armpit, then double it.
  • Length: from the highest point of the shoulder down to the hem. For a skirt, measure from the waistband to the hem.
  • Sleeve: from the shoulder seam to the end of the sleeve.
  • Skirt waist and hips: across the waistband and across the hips, then double each.

Now you can compare like with like: your favorite garment against the chart for the new one.

Step 3: Read the Size Chart the Right Way

On our product pages, click What's my size? under the price. You'll find two tools: a size calculator that suggests a size from your age, height and weight, and the size chart for that item, in inches or centimeters.

A few things to know when reading a chart:

  • Our charts are garment measurements, taken with the item laid flat. The chart explains how each measurement is taken. If an item stretches, its chart or description may say how much, and some of our charts do. Where they don't, compare the chart with a similar garment you own rather than assuming extra stretch.
  • On our skirt size charts, the waist is shown as a range. Choose a size whose waist range includes your own waist measurement, so the skirt sits comfortably.
  • Skirt length tells you where the hem will fall. Hold a tape measure from your waist down your leg to see where that is on you.
  • Reviews help. Customers often say whether an item ran small or large.

As a rough guide, our adult sizes follow standard US sizing:

Kosher Casual US women's
XS 2
S 4–6
M 8
L 10–12
XL 14
2XL 16
3XL 18

The product chart for the item always wins over this table.

Step 4: Decide How You Want It to Fit

Fit affects coverage, comfort and how an outfit looks, and the right answer depends on the garment.

Layering pieces: usually close-fitting by design

A layer goes under other clothes, so it's designed to sit smoothly against the body. Many of our layering tops are made to be worn fitted, and the right size will feel fitted.

  • Too large: the layer bunches under your clothes and adds the bulk you were trying to avoid.
  • Too small: stretch fabric thins out over the bust and shoulders and can ride up.

Read each description. Some layers have their own advice:

Skirts: room through the hips

For a skirt you'll sit, walk and bend in all day, look for room through the hips rather than sizing up the waist. A skirt that's too tight across the hips pulls, wrinkles and can ride up when you sit.

If you're between sizes in a stretch skirt, compare your hip measurement with the chart first.

Tops and dresses you'll wear on their own

Many women who dress modestly prefer a little ease, so the fabric skims rather than clings. If you want that, compare a top you already find comfortable with the chart, rather than automatically sizing up. Going up a size also makes shoulders, sleeves and length bigger, which can look sloppy.

For more on getting this balance right, see the difference between "loose" and "flattering".

Accessories with their own sizing

Step 5: Do a Coverage Check When It Arrives

Try it on before you remove the tags, and move the way you will in real life:

  • Sit down and check where the hem lands.
  • Bend forward and check the neckline.
  • Raise your arms and check the sleeves and hem.
  • Stand near a window to check that the fabric isn't see-through.

If something isn't right, see our FAQ for how returns work, or chat with us on the site before you order.

A Size Is Just a Number

Going up a size or two doesn't mean you've gained weight, and a smaller size doesn't mean you've lost any. It's usually just the cut. A size is a measuring aid, not a judgment of your body. Choose the piece that fits you in the right places and that you'll be comfortable and confident wearing all day.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I size up for a modest fit?

Not automatically. Sizing up makes everything bigger, including shoulders, sleeves and length. Compare a garment you already like with the product's size chart, and follow the item's own fit notes.

What if I'm between two sizes?

Follow the item's own fit notes first. If there are none, compare a garment you already like with the chart, read the reviews, or ask us on chat before you order.

Why do I wear one size in your skirts and another in your tops?

Different garments are cut and measured differently, and many of our layering tops are designed to be worn fitted. Use the chart for each item.

Do your sizes match standard US sizes?

Our adult sizes are based on standard US sizes; for example, Medium is about a US 8. The chart on each product page is the best guide.

For more help, see our sizing guidelines, or read about dressing for your body shape and how we're improving the fit of our basics.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published